Investigate Two

Introductions

How you as an analyst handle true positives is life and death in the eyes of potential victims. Traditionally the industry elected to prioritize overzealousness and sending more than not to cover their failings, This however is no different to guesses and it is possible to arrive at strong data-backed decisions on events that could be the compromise of an estate

True Positive

True positives exist at the heart of all our jobs, they are what we wake up for in the
morning and why we endlessly pursue understanding how to protect our clients. The
strictest possible definition of true positive is where an outcome of a prediction or model
is returned true. This broad definition is important because the assumption carried with
a predication or model can change. As an example many security technologies aim to
identify when an application often unwanted by an organization is present within a
system, these are commonly dubbed PUPs. (Potentially Unwanted Programs).


The general consensus is that PUPs do not bring an immediate threat to an
organization however when you traditionally compare the qualities of a PUP vs another
file, qualities of that PUP will be more suggestive of an opportunity to be abused. As
such when security technologies identify PUPs they are considered True Positives.


Considering other models or projections abstracted by detections is important when
establishing the criticality of your investigation and where on the spectrum of criticality
you land. Another common example is the deletion of shadow volumes. Often alerts
derived from detections looking for Shadow Volume copies being enumerated and
removed will label themselves “Ransomware Activity”.


Now on your own review of these alerts you may find that a shadow volume copy was
removed but it was a necessary step in an organization’s backup process. So from the
perspective of the model or prediction it successfully raised a true positive however from
analysts’ perspective, it was a false positive because an analyst’s own model or
prediction will always be “Was this an adversary”



This mindset is critical because you may look at numerous true positives a day and of
course even more false positives, but it is expected of an analyst to know out of the
noise which true positive needs escalating into greater human eyes or simply forward to
a client as a polite reminder.



Ugly True Positives

Now that we have explored how different true positives can exist I have coined the term
“Ugly True positive’ to denote those that must initiate major incident response
procedures when found. Ugly true positives are measured by how much impact the next
possible action could cause. As an example (colours will darken as the more ugly the investigation leads)




Immediately with the information we have in the table we will want to establish whether
authentication attempts from Canada normally occur.
While asking these investigative questions we can already start thinking about if this
was an event generated by an adversary they would now have access to the data the account does





We now have more information and can ask our self “What data specifically would an
adversary have access to within Exchange Online”
Exchange online can have huge scope and what people can access is largely
dependant on ACLs configured within the app and unfortunately not something present
in our events,

We can now view what activity occurred within the app exchange online after the
date./time of the authentication request


After the successful authentication, the same user established an inbox rule to forward
emails from the domain “@contoso” to Conversation History. We know the location of
Conversation History within a mailbox is scarcely used let only for an inbox rule.
Adversaries are well known to perform this technique to allow themselves and the victim
to persist in the mailbox at the same time


Now what we are investigating is starting to get ugly, at first, we had a true positive but
on its own it meant nothing to us and now we are seeing activity occur that we wouldn’t
expect a human to do.’ At this point, you want to increase the amount of energy we are
expending because we have moved to post-compromise activity which is the ugliest of
all.





An analysts nightmare

Below are some tell tall signs you have found an ugly true positive:

  • Identification of initial access followed by escalating activity
  • Recurrence of the same alert across multiple assets
  • Unrelated alerts converging on a common objective


Analyst Response

Once you have understood the type of true positive and the concept of “what is the
worst that could happen next” to establish how critical the true positive is you now need
to decide how you are going to respond. At minimum, for all true positives, you must

  • Document its discovery and your classification
  • Detail your investigative steps
  • Inform the local team
  • What actions you would like to take further

However, if you are presented with or have discovered an ugly true positive
  • Escalate to team leadership
  • Articulate the severity and the data you used.
  • Prepare for containment and post-compromise assessment
Once immediate actions are completed as an analyst you will want to switch tracks towards" How can we learn from this", "what role did our controls place in this and did they behave expectedly". You as the analyst need to take ownership of your findings and conclusions and declare what you investigate malicious or a false positive. Do not attempt to pass it along let it slide as a notification of something suspicious 



Engineering the Ugly True Positives




If you build detections and engineer how those detections exist within a lifecycle you
need to be measuring how severe a situation it is if the detection fires. Using context a
detection should behave in different ways.

Some detections should skip 200 and go straight to jail alerting and ultimately executing
major incident response procedures immediately for example when 200 of the largest
EC2 instance plans are span up in under an hour. But some detections need to serve as
little pieces to a puzzle like “connections made on high-ranged ports for new binaries”
being joined to “new binary spawning script interpreter” and as these little puzzle pieces
build up to a threshold that is established and if lapsed you have your self an Ugly true
positive.

How the detections manifest to analysts can go a long way too, the words High
Severity and the Colour Red doesn’t really carry any conscious weight in the mind
when asking investigative questions. So explicitly detail what an adversary could
achieve if the activity is a true positive, what data is at risk and include tips, tricks and
pivot points to get to more pertinent data faster

In addition, if as an engineer you have devised logic that has a high certainty of a trigger
being a True Postive, review the analysts own processes for such an occasion and see
if you can alleviate each step. In particular, if you know that after a business email
compromise-related detection analysts will want to receive all the FileDownload
OfficeActivity operations have those results immediately ready in the alert.

Furthermore, dedicate time to thoroughly investigate your detections and formulate qualitative benchmarks to enhance their reliability. This preparation will empower you to incorporate switch response and containment measures when confronted with "ugly true positives" all without requiring manual intervention 

Presentation to analysts in an art, with clarity trumping generic severity labels. Envisioning an adversary's potential exploits and offering strategic pivots to facilitate an efficient investigation. Tailing detections to analyst workflow streamlines their process. enabling rapid action. the fusion of distinct detections amplifies their collective impact and constructs timelines for comprehensive analysis

You could summarize the role of an engineer during an active investigation as bringing the lead > causality time down to as short as possible.

Summary

When performing an investigation and you arrive to a decision point think about what
the impact of the events could mean, think about the abnormality of it. how would the
activity give an adversary an advantage and is it an already known procedure?




Popular

Endpoint on Adrenaline : One

Image
Introduction   This blog series will capture how to maximise the protection of an endpoint using the various technologies in the Defender suite. The controls outlined in the series will each need to have their own considerations taken into account for a given environment but hopefully at a minimum it will be clear just how powerful of an offering Microsoft has.  Unfortunately due to the highly modular and distinct diversity in controls Microsoft offers things are often overlooked and misconfigured when tests are conducted. With this in mind, the shortest possible route to a solution for this is utilizing the recommendations, CSPM and Secure Score technology contained within Defender 365 and Defender for Cloud as it will automatically conduct posture assessments and inform you of things you have missed and may want to turn on (IE dont take these recommendations lightly) Lastly, I would recommend reading the book “Defender for Endpoint in depth” from packt as it showcases the co...
Read more

Brilliance in the Basics

Image
Introduction Tired of watching you and your friends get compromised, do exactly what's in this blog and start beating adversaries. Avoiding the memes adversaries win because of simple mistakes and neglect and we all already know what they are so I'm going to list them for you. Its all for free too. Enumerate To put it simply, there shouldn't be anything you don't know about your environment, you should know who all your users are, where all your electronic devices are and what they do, what applications you have and what versions they are. Enumeration is the jet fuel for making good defensive decisions. I wrote about how to enumerate your environment here  Securing your estate: The First Step (goblinloot.net) . Follow these steps and become the arbitrator of your own environment  Your perimeter is a bridge, not a wall Monitor your perimeter as best as you can but always assume it has already been defeated. Monitor endpoint system and process telemetry and southwest traf...
Read more

Investigate

Image
  Introduction This document details how an analyst should conduct investigations and triage in the normal duties of their job. It will describe concepts and logic that enable analysts to look at data, ask investigative questions, evaluate those questions and arrive at assertions about what they have found. An Alert For the most part, analysts begin their investigative work when an alert is generated. Alerts are fantastic because they are a statement that something has happened and something needs to be done about it. Typically alerts are filled with information that an analyst can then use in their investigation. Alerts are generated by detections and these detections can come in many shapes and sizes. Some just look for a particular action like someone unlocking their car door, others might have access to more context like someone who isn’t the owner of the car unlocking the door. Going even further some detections might look at how the car door was opened or at w...
Read more

Endpoint on Adrenaline 3

Image
Introduction Now that I have covered the advanced features obtained from Defender for Cloud and the complexities of Defender for Endpoint with the objective of delivering as much protection as possible to the endpoint, I will now explore how to expand on this greatly and open up even more use cases. Microsoft Sentinel This technology will allow us to unify and correlate data generated by other controls. I have decided to deploy Microsoft Sentinel into 4 primary categories : System Administrator - Asset Uptime, Application Inventory, Device configuration and Troubleshooting Network Engineers - Netflow and session traffic, violations and alerts for potential issues Threat Detection - Analytics and playbooks Threat hunting - Workbooks & Machine learning Using Microsoft Sentinel we can achieve a plethora of incredibly powerful use cases with Defender 365 endpoint data. Below is an illustration of how my SIEM works to enable analysts to prevent and detect threats Data Sources In order t...
Read more

Writing detections when stuck with EDR

Image
Introduction Making the leap to purchasing and maintaining an EDR solution can be huge for organisations so huge in fact that they never really progress from there when it comes to visibility on assets. This is an important consideration because organisations should aim to achieve some level of detection engineering but will likely never get to explore the associated complexities. So how can organisations effectively and easily write detections that actually help to protect them when they are only able to leverage an EDR tool. Understanding your tools limitations To most people EDR tools are incredibly verbose in the telemetry they capture from any given asset but unfortunately relative to overall telemetry available they actually only capture what the vendors think is the most pertinent. This is for obvious reasons because ingesting telemetry at the scale vendors do comes at a significant cost so they implement "cost-saving measures" like limiting the amount of any one given...
Read more

Endpoint on Adrenaline Two

Image
Introduction Continuing on from my last post that captured using Defender for Cloud to gain powerful additional features on top of defender for endpoint to protect your endpoints we are going to take a closer look at Defender for Endpoint itself and extend into some endpoint-specific use cases for Defender for Identity that tie directly back into Defender for Endpoint. Firstly a really important consideration when configuring Defender for Endpoint is that alot of the heavy lifting from a prevention standpoint actually happens in Defender Anti virus. This means that while im going to briefly cover some settings to make sure Defender Anti Virus isnt hindering Defender for Endpoint im going to reserve further Defender Anti Virus controls to the next part in this series. This also of course means that when your doing your own testing just installing the MSSense agent (What you get from the scripts, intune etc) is actually not Defender for Endpoint in its totality so you simply can not m...
Read more

Why you need to be purple!

Image
 It's Bad For those who have worked with me for longer periods, you would have heard me say at least once that I don't believe in the commonly prescribed structure of blue and red team operations as much as there are good intentions behind the separation of operations, human behaviour has prevailed and there exists a quite toxic environment between the two (wrongly opposing) sides. This is a direct contradiction to  our purpose in cybersecurity which is to harden environments and increase resiliency to cyber-attacks. We need to change While purple teaming was not created to replace blue and red operations I have adopted it to do exactly that. Too often I experience clashes between red team operators and defenders whether its online shouting contests or during client engagements behaviour that does not support the iterative improvement of cybersecurity is simply not welcome. Particularly SOC analysts will know this as they will have experienced their fair share of red team en...
Read more

Standardized Note Taking Format For Analysts

Image
  Introduction This post outlines a format for note-taking designed to aid analysts and ensure the knowledge they acquire over time is kept so that it can easily be consumed later. This format is designed to be technology agnostic so it can be applied to a note-taking tool or platform of the analyst’s choice. I designed this format because analysts often received what you could call unplanned information whereby at any given moment during their day they could learn something highly impactful to their role via any medium. This really exasperates the need for good note-taking practices for analysts. Illustrated above is the wireframe that analysts can implement into their note-taking platforms. Each section contains sub-sections that allow for different knowledge to remain segregated and more searchable. Meeting Notes Within any given week analysts can have countless meetings and so it is important to note down items from meetings for future review. Not every meeting needs to be ...
Read more

Securing your estate: The First Step

Introduction A commonly forgotten fact within the cybersecurity industry is that most organizations are not equipped nor have started to form any sort of security program. This is the case for many reasons because most organizations are SMBs so they don't and likely will never have funds to purchase people and technology and the fact that the cybersecurity industry is incredibly toxic for low expertise and or low capability teams as the well of knowledge we all rely on has been poisoned by vendors and 'thought leaders'. With this in mind, I have created a small resource that will guide you through what you need to do to make a start. This resource won't reference vendors and I will try to avoid specific jargon. Enumerate The term 'You can't secure what you don't know' stands strong even to this day and should be your primary focus before you do anything else. Understanding what assets, you have both physically (computer hardware) and logically (applicati...
Read more